Article published in the journal: Gary Glassman, DDS, and Sam Kratchman, DMD cv`s information below.
Article published in the journal Dentistry Today | September 2011
Since the late 1950s, the use of ultrasonic technology has become a staple in endodontic practices around the world for hygiene and periodontal procedures. More recently, endodontists have introduced us to the clinical advantages of their use in root canal therapy, and we are just beginning to see their effectiveness for endo-restorative and microrestorative work.
This article will review the expanded function that ultrasonic technology has taken in root canal therapy, why piezoelectric technology is well matched to endodontics, current clinical uses and advances in both ultrasonic equipment and tips, and some of the science behind the technology.
Ultrasonics used for operative and preventative procedures are usually divided into 2 groups:
Figure 1. Inside a Satelec Handpiece
The word "piezo" comes from the Greek piezein, which means to push, press, or squeeze. In 1880, Jacques and Pierre Curie discovered a curious characteristic of certain crystalline minerals: when subjected to a mechanical force, the crystals became electrically polarized. The converse is also true – if a voltage-generating crystal is exposed to an electric field, it lengthens or shortens, depending on the polarity of the field, and in proportion to the strength of the field. This scientific effect has therefore been used in piezoultrasonics: electrical current generates a wave in the crystals (ie, series of ceramic discs or quartz plates inside the handpiece of the ultrasonic), which is transferred to the ultrasonic tip (Figure 1). This creates a linear back-and-forth tip motion, which is ideal for many dental procedures, such as subgingival scaling, and of course, endodontic use. In the above-mentioned process, very little heat is generated in the handpiece. Unlike magnetorestrictive type ultrasonics, water is not supplied to cool the handpiece; it is simply used to cool the tooth and tip, as needed. If water is used, a low volume aerosol mist is all that is required, improving vision and patient comfort. Piezo units also do not vibrate in the operator's hand, greatly improving the ergonomics. The following is a brief review of some of the applications of the piezoelectric ultrasonics and the associated variety of tips.
The first piezoelectric ultrasonic was introduced to the market by Satelec in the late 1970s. Since that time, there has been an evolution in the technology, operation, ergonomics, and the design of the machines. The most important feature of any ultrasonic unit is how it maneuvers the tip and adjusts to many different tip designs (each with an unique intended function). A good ultrasonic machine also must adapt to several unpredictable clinical conditions and tooth anatomy. It must be remembered that "the mechanism of ultrasonics is very different than other instruments,"1 such as a high-speed handpiece. As Dr. David Clark (Tacoma, Wash) has noted in this journal, it is somewhat "counterintuitive"; increased manual pressure or cranking up the power does not necessarily add cutting or vibrating efficiency. In many cases, it reduces efficiency.
There are 2 variables of ultrasonic tip vibration: the frequency (number of times the tip moves back and forth every second) and power or intensity (the amplitude or arc of the tip movement, which is usually operator controlled). When the power is turned up, the frequency does not change; the "power" simply increases the back-and-forth arc (amplitude) of the tip. One of the latest advances in piezo "drive" technology is the Newtron (Satelec) line of ultraonics (Figures 2 and 3).
|Figure 2. P5 Newtron, Satelec (ACTEON North America)||Figure 3. P5 Newtron XS, Satelec|
The module, which controls each unit, features "cruise control" consisting of 3 quite advanced functions:
Many design elements are incorporated into a number of high-quality piezoelectric models. Optional fiber-optic or LED handpieces (Figure 4) (ie, optional on the Varios by NSK and the Satelec Newtron models) certainly enhance visibility, but may be an unnessecary expense if the operator is using a high-powered LED headlight (Figure 5) or a microscope. In any event, intense light, good magnification through loupes or a microscope, and reliable ultrasonic technology are all a must if you are doing molar endodontics. Water has always been inherent to ultrasonic use; being necessary in magnetorestrictive units to cool the handpiece, the tooth surface, and the tip. Piezoelectric units still require the use of water in periodontal and hygiene procedures, but for most endodontic applications water is discretionary. For example, in operations such as access refinement and chasing calcified canals, much dentinal dust is created. This, when mixed with water, tends to become a slurry that might bog down the ultrasonic instrument, and will certainly obscure the clinician's vision.
|Figure 4. Optional LED handpiece for piezo|
|Figure 5. POV Led headlight (Clinical Research Dental)||Figure 6. Irrigation port on ultrasonic tip|
However, there are advantages to intermittent water use. For example, when using an ultrasonic tip to remove a metal post by vibrating it, the heat generated can cause thermal injury to teeth and their supporting structures. In reporting on this possibility, Gluskin, et al2 recommended as part of a good protocol for post removal using ultrasonics, "Use devices that allow water to reach the working end of the ultrasonic tip to provide maximum cooling effect." Furthermore, the occasional use of water in endodontic access refinement yields a clean surface and can expose what many clinicians refer to as a "dentinal roadmap"; for instance: differentiating the pulp chamber floor from secondary dentin, possibly providing clues to the location of a hidden canal, and properly orienting the operator in order to begin achieving a good Glidepath, and getting the cleaning and shaping process off to a good start. As it would appear that intermittent water use is advantageous, it would follow that ultrasonic tips that have water ports are preferred over tips without (Figure 6). The availability of a stream of air during ultrasonic use is also necessary. It also will act as a coolant, and a steady stream of precisely directed air can help keep clear visibility, blowing away dentinal and other dust and debris. The use of a Stropko irrigator (Stropko) (Figures 7 to 10), adapted to your air-water syringe, allows your assistant to direct an optimal fine stream of air to the operative field.
|Figures 7 to 10. Stropko Irrigator (Stropko), tips, and clinical use|
"Tooth retention has increased significantly in older adults, and dentists are now challenged by the need to preserve critical teeth."3 Clinicians are confronted with calcified canals, pulp stones, and hidden canals such as in maxillary molars (MB2).4,5 According to peer-reviewed literature, second mesial buccal canals are present in most maxilliary molars. Dr. John Stropko examined 1,732 conventionally treated maxillary molars over a period of several years in a very impressive clinical study. He noted, "As the operator became more experienced, scheduled sufficient clinical time, routinely employed the dental operating microscope, and used specific instruments adapted for microendodontics, MB2 canals were located in 93.0% of first molars and 60.4% in second molars."6 There are 3 key factors mentioned here: a certain level of familiarity in treating MB2s, allowing adequate time, proper magnification, and using the correct instruments (Figures 11a and 11b). For both general practitioners and endodontists, the ultrasonic is a valuable tool to treat calcified and difficult to find canals, as long as it is complemented by the proper tip, and sufficient magnification and light.7,8 It is less aggressive than a high-speed handpiece, and with high magnification the operator can always see where the tip is and where it is heading. By contrast, the high-speed handpiece affords little if any visibility in access procedures, so the dentist must constantly stop, look, and start again to avoid procedural mishaps. As Dr. L. Stephen Buchanan9 says, "Any clinician who performs molar endodontics without ultrasonics is working too hard, is experiencing more anxiety than is necessary, and is most likely not finding MB2 canals in more than 40% of their maxillary molar cases."
|Figures 11a and 11b. Uncovering a calcified canal in a maxillary molar. (Courtesy of Dr. Helmut Walsch, Germany)|
Dental manufacturers today have brought us a variety of tips and cutting surfaces such as smooth stainless steel, zirconium nitride, and diamond coated tips. Recent studies have suggested that diamond coated surfaces offer some of the best cutting efficiency;10 however, diamond particles can fall out and wear down rapidly, making ultrasonic tips dull and much less efficient all too soon. A newer entry to the marketplace is the BL series of tips (B&L Biotech/Clinical Research Dental) (Figure 12a). Instead of a diamond coating, BL tips have integrated sharp micro-projections (small raised bumps) on the tip surface, which engage the tooth surface precisely and efficiently. The active abrasive surface has considerably more longevity than other coated tips, and they are less expensive due to the lack of an additional coating process.
|Figure 12a. BL tips (B&L Biotech/Clinical Research Dental). Figures 12b to 12d. BL-1 and -2 in the pulp chamber.|
The BL tip set consists of:
|Figures 13 a-c. BL-5 tips used deeper in the canal. (Courtesy of Dr. Yoshi Terauchi, Japan)|
Advancements in canal shaping instruments and techniques have led to a much greater emphasis on root canal irrigation protocols. High volume and frequent exchange of sodium hypochlorite throughout the cleaning and shaping procedure is acknowledged to be essential to success. However, complete removal of canal organic and inorganic debris, especially from the apical third and webs, fins, and lateral canals continues to be a challenge.
Ultrasonic use to activate irrigant in the canal has shown to be a clinically proven and efficient adjunct to cleaning and shaping instrument sequences and is used by many endodontic specialists.11-13 Ultrasonic activation of irrigants produces at least 2 helpful effects:
|Figures 14 a-c. Irrisafe (Clinical Research Dental) tips for irrigation (ACETON North America/Clinical Research Dental).|
An excellent ultrasonic tip instrument to create this type of passive ultrasonic irrigation is the Irrisafe file (Satelec/ ACTEON North America). This a long, thin, parallel tip which resembles a K-type file, but with non-cutting, rounded flutes (Figures 14a to 14c). These flutes affect the aforementioned acoustic streaming, but will not engage the dentin or transport the canal. To use these tips effectively, the canal is filled with sodium hypochlorite (use the 31-gauge NaviTip [Ultradent Products] with 2 side ports offset to each other, and capped at the end) (Figures 15a and 15b). The Irrisafe tip is activated in the canal at low-to-medium power at least one mm short of working length for one minute in each canal. The irrigant may then be evacuated out with a Luer Vac Adapter (Ultradent Products) (Figure 16). This clinically and scientifically accepted method of passive ultrasonic irrigation helps push the ultrasonic from luxury into necessity status!14,15
In the natural course of the life of a dental practice, specialty or general, cases will present that will require retreatment of a previously restored, endodontically treated tooth. This will often entail disassembly of the restoration, perhaps including removal of a metal post, a silver point, gutta-percha, obturation carriers, etc. There is also the possibility of instrument separation during root canal therapy, which usually requires immediate intervention. The piezoelectric ultrasonic is also an invaluable tool for these procedures. In such situations, good case selection is very critical; frequently the endodontist has the proficiency to handle these procedures, having been well educated on the justification and protocols for retreatment, possessing valuable experience in retreating many cases over many years, and having all the instruments and tools essential to deal with the most difficult, unusual, and sometimes unforeseen conditions under which most retreatment is done.16
|Figures 15a and 15b. The 31-gauge double-side port NaviTip Irrigation needle (Ultradent Products/Clinical Research Dental).|
Metal post removal is a laborious and time consuming chore that can be made easier with the use of the proper ultrasonic tip. A tip, which will engage and fit over the post or contact directly and vibrate the post, can break up the crystalline structure of the post cement, thus loosening it enough to be removed. Sometimes the operator must take this a step further, following up with a long and more slender tip to trough around the post, steadily loosening and eventually extricating it. In these cases, water should be used periodically to keep the tooth cool to avoid the earlier stated "thermal injury." The same approach can be used to remove other obstructions such as silver points, obturation carriers, pins, and separated nikel-titanium or stainless steel files. Choice of the proper tip is paramount.
For removal of obstructions in the canal, here are some guidelines to keep in mind:
In addition to the above, it cannot be overstated that excellent visibility, good magnification, and proper illumination are all vital for success in these ultrasonic uses. Experience and good case selection is also vitally important.
|Figure 16. Luer Vac Adaptor (Ultradent Products/Clinical Research Dental) used for evacuating irrigant and canal drying. Figure||17. JET Surgical Tip (B&L Biotech/Clinical Research Dental). (Case courtesy of Dr. Marga Ree, Netherlands)|
Ultrasonics are also presently used in removing gutta-percha, condensing gutta-percha, vibrating perforation repair material, such as mineral trioxide aggregate, into location, and root end surgical preparation (Figure 17). Currently, there are an increasing number of restorative procedures, which are ideal for ultrasonic applications such as margin finishing, interproximal and small lingual restorations, and more advances in oral surgical applications are in development.
Less than 2 decades after the endodontic specialty introduced this as a marvelous tool for endodontics, ultrasonic use for endodontics is here to stay. Most dentists, who use ultrasonics for endodontic procedures acknowledge that this technology can help solve many clinical problems and challenges in treating complex root canal systems. As has been said, "Habit converts luxury into necessity." A growing number of clinicians performing endodontics are adding the piezoelectric ultrasonic and tips to the list of endodontic "necessities."
Dr. Glassman graduated from the University of Toronto, Faculty of Dentistry in 1984 and graduated from the endodontology program at Temple University in 1987, where he received the Louis I. Grossman Study Club Award for academic and clinical proficiency in endodontics. The author of numerous publications, Dr. Glassman lectures globally on endodontics and is on staff at the University of Toronto, Faculty of Dentistry in the graduate department of endodontics. He is a Fellow of the Royal College of Dentists of Canada, and the endodontic editor for Oral Health. He maintains a private practice, Endodontic Specialists in Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Disclosure: Dr. Glassman reports no disclosures.
Dr. Kratchman received a BS in biology and a DMD from Tufts University in Boston, Mass. He then entered the University of Pennsylvania, where he received a certificate of endodontics and currently serves as an associate professor of endodontics and the assistant director of graduate endodontics, in charge of the microsurgical portion of the program. Dr. Kratchman has authored several articles and chapters on endodontics and intentional replantation for the Microsurgery in Endodontics textbook, and the Dental Clinics of North America. He also developed a patented instrument called the S Kondenser for the obturation of root canals. He serves as the District I director for the American Association of Endodontists. Both Main Line Today and Doctor of Dentistry magazines honored Dr. Kratchman as the cover story for their "Best of" issues. Dr. Kratchman lectures on several topics relating to endodontics throughout the United States, Europe, Scandinavia, South America, and Asia. He also maintains 3 private practices, limited to endodontics, in Exton, Ardmore, and West Chester, Penn.
Disclosure: Dr. Kratchman receives royalties from Obtura Spartan for gutta-percha condensers.